Let us walk in the shoes of Scott, who has worked as the VP of Card Services for a local financial institution for ten years. He has been promoted over the past decade from a Card Services Rep role while in college and worked up to the department head. He feels pride in his accomplishments and hopes to rise even higher in the organization. Then, suddenly, there is an announcement of a merger. They call it a merger of equals, but everyone recognizes that the other larger company is assimilating them. Scott is concerned about whether he can trust the promise of no layoffs or whether a similar role in the other company will replace his role or title. How will duplication of roles be handled? He was very proud of his VP title. Scott had worked with some of his colleagues, including his boss, for over a decade. It was a big part of what he enjoyed most about his job. 

During a merger or acquisition (M&A), HR leaders must strategically battle compensation-related issues, such as varying compensation philosophies and job architectures, to elevate employee experience and retention rates. It is vital to get HR involved early on in the process. Unfortunately, examining and identifying variances in compensation strategies is typically only done well after the ink is dried. Following the close of the deal, HR begins to work through a formal job architecture. This is a lengthy process, complicated by the fact that perhaps neither of the companies had a formal job architecture. Instead, they have given title bumps to boost morale at critical moments in their corporate development for specific employees. Using outside consultants for a thorough job analysis and salary range recommendation based on the new job architecture is often extremely helpful in demonstrating a commitment to objectivity. Some key strategic compensation issues include:

 

Pay Equity and Harmonization:

Mergers often result in employees performing similar roles but being compensated differently. It’s crucial to ensure fairness and equity across the combined workforce. Harmonizing compensation structures, benchmarking pay against industry standards, and addressing disparities is paramount to maintaining employee morale and preventing talent attrition. Reporting structures often change, which interrupts long-term working relationships. This can drastically impact work satisfaction. 

 

Retention of Key Talent:

Top performers and key talent are vital assets that drive organizational success. In the wake of a merger, there is a risk of losing these individuals due to uncertainty or dissatisfaction with compensation, cultural changes, or a lack of trust in job security. Identifying and incentivizing key talent through retention bonuses, performance-based incentives, or sometimes equity grants can mitigate this risk and ensure continuity in critical roles.

 

Culture Alignment:

Compensation is deeply intertwined with organizational culture. When merging with or acquiring another company, compensation philosophies or practice disparities can lead to cultural friction. Aligning compensation frameworks with the overarching organizational culture, values, and objectives is essential for fostering a cohesive and engaged workforce. One organization may have had a strong sales culture and actively utilized incentive pay or annual bonuses based on corporate goals. In contrast, other organizations may have richer-than-market benefits. 

 

Communication and Transparency:

Transparent communication regarding compensation changes is vital for fostering trust and mitigating resistance during a merger or acquisition. Employees must understand the rationale behind compensation adjustments, the timelines for implementation, and how their individual contributions are valued within the new organization. Open dialogue and clear messaging from leadership can alleviate uncertainty and apprehension among employees.

 

Legal and Regulatory Compliance:

Mergers and acquisitions entail navigating a complex legal and regulatory requirements landscape, particularly concerning compensation and benefits. Compliance with labor laws, tax regulations, and contractual obligations is non-negotiable. Ensuring alignment with regulatory frameworks and seeking legal counsel to navigate potential pitfalls is imperative to safeguarding an organization’s reputation and minimizing legal risks.

 

Integration of Total Rewards:

Compensation extends beyond base salaries to encompass a range of rewards, including benefits, incentives, and recognition programs. Integrating total rewards offerings from both entities requires a comprehensive assessment of benefits packages, retirement plans, wellness programs, and other perks to create a cohesive and competitive compensation package that attracts and retains top talent.

 

Know your talent and meet them where they are:

Understand who is critical to the future of the company and be quick to develop and execute employee retention plans at all levels of the organization, not just your executives.

 

Engage your stakeholders:

Where possible, bring leaders along the journey and empower them to make informed decisions. Leaders must understand and be bought into the “Why?” and understand how to effectively communicate good or bad news with their teams as authentically and empathically as possible.

Strategic foresight, meticulous planning, and a people-centric approach are indispensable in navigating the complex landscape of compensation issues during a merger or acquisition. Once key decisions are made, communicating clearly, concisely, and empathically to all stakeholders is important. While employee sentiment is likely to always be somewhat skeptical during a merger, by proactively addressing these considerations, we can ensure a smooth transition, preserve employee engagement, and position our organization for sustained success in the evolving business landscape.

Back to Blog