Navigating Bonus Disappointment: A Guide for Senior Managers

By Christie Summervill

Navigating Bonus Disappointment: A Guide for Senior Managers

Most senior managers at financial institutions are accustomed to receiving an annual bonus to recognize the hard work and dedication that resulted in accomplishing corporate goals. However, there may be instances where such expected compensation is withheld. This can lead to feelings of betrayal, outrage, and storming off to recruiting websites. Hold up! In such situations, it’s crucial to navigate this disappointment constructively.

Stay Calm and Composed:

First and foremost, remaining calm and composed is essential when you receive the news. Reactions driven by frustration or anger are not productive. Take some time to process your emotions before discussing the matter further. Your support system for processing this is never your colleagues or work associates.

Seek Clarity:

Reach out to the CEO to understand the reasons behind the decision. Sometimes, unforeseen circumstances may affect the company’s financial performance or your individual performance targets. It’s essential to clarify the specific factors that led to the decision. The problem is exacerbated when bonuses are given at the discretion of the CEO, as this gives the appearance of partiality and indiscriminate rationale, which often leads to feelings of hopelessness. It can even lead to allegations of other motivations based on race, religion, gender, or other protected classes. It is always best to clarify the basis for the short-term annual bonus and even update midyear.

Reflect on Your Performance:

Self-reflection is a critical step. Assess your performance objectively. Did you meet or exceed your performance goals? Were there areas that needed improvement? Identifying areas for growth can help you prepare for future evaluations.

Have the Data:

Be sure you can prove your position’s average asset size bonus. Use multiple industry-specific sources.

Consider the Bigger Picture:

Annual bonuses are just one part of your total compensation package. Evaluate the overall benefits and long-term growth potential within the company. Other advantages, such as promotional opportunities or stock options, can sometimes offset a smaller bonus.

Professional Development:

Use this situation as an opportunity for professional growth. Seek out training, mentorship, or projects to enhance your skills and increase your value to the organization. Demonstrating a commitment to your self-development can be a positive step forward. Ask the decision makers if your growth in a particular area would be perceived as valuable to the organization.

Financial Planning:

Financial planning is essential, especially when you anticipate a lower income due to the absence of an annual bonus. Review your financial goals, budget, and savings plan to maintain your financial stability.

Stay Engaged and Motivated:

It’s crucial to remain engaged and motivated in your role, even when faced with a bonus disappointment. Your continued dedication and hard work can position you for future opportunities within the organization.

Base Pay Consideration:

How does your base pay compare to the midpoint of the salary range? People understand if/when the current economy overall does not allow for any senior bonus in a specific year, which is why base pay must be commensurate with the market rate for the amount of experience in the role. With five years of experience in an executive position, the incumbent would usually be paid at the midpoint.

Revisit Your Goals:

Use this moment to revisit your career goals and aspirations. Assess if your current role and organization still align with your long-term objectives. If not, it may be time to consider other career opportunities.


Click here to view BalancedComp’s 2023 Bank Incentive Pay Report for average annual bonuses by asset size.

Click here to view BalancedComp’s 2023 Credit Union Incentive Pay Report for average annual bonuses by asset size.


In conclusion, not receiving an annual bonus can be highly disappointing, especially if not properly notified in advance to expect something less than prior years. That said, it’s important to approach the situation with a constructive mindset. You can use this experience as a catalyst for personal and professional growth by seeking clarity, self-reflecting, and maintaining open communication. Remember that your value as a senior manager extends beyond financial incentives, and your commitment to excellence will continue to be recognized within a good organization.

Back to Blog